Pax (funcrunch) wrote,

All creatures great and small

While walking down the street today I spotted a beautiful butterfly sitting in the middle of the sidewalk. It seemed like an odd place to find such a creature. I bent down close, and it did not fly away. I feared it must be injured. I extended my hand, and it climbed up onto my finger. I held it aloft and admired it for a minute or so. Then I gently placed it on a nearby flowering bush, and went on my way.

I thought about this natural impulse to protect and admire such an animal, a lowly insect. Most people would be alarmed at an adult who would intentionally tear off a butterfly's wings, and reprimand a child for doing so. But most of these same people would eat the wings of a chicken with no qualms whatsoever.

What is the difference between a butterfly and a chicken, from a moral perspective? A butterfly is certainly not more intelligent than a chicken; some doubt that insects are even sentient. Is it beauty? Some butterflies are quite homely, and some chickens quite beautiful.

Is it that there is no good reason to tear off a butterfly's wings? What if a person gets pleasure from doing so? Is that sufficient justification? If not, why is it sufficient justification for eating a chicken? Or eggs, given that virtually all egg-laying chickens in this country are ultimately killed for low-quality meat?

When it comes to my diet, I find it most morally consistent to draw a bright line at the animal kingdom. I don't spend time trying to decide whether an animal, or its milk or eggs, is worth consuming based on its intelligence, beauty, or what quality of life it might have had. I do not know if a butterfly feels pain in the same way that I would, or a chicken would, if I pull off her wings. But I know I have the moral sense that it is the wrong thing to do, and that it is not necessary to do so. I extend this same level of courtesy to all creatures, great and small.
Tags: vegan

  • Race report: Kaiser Permanente Half Marathon

    It seems I only use LiveJournal for blogging about racing nowadays. I've been much more active (too active, really) on Facebook on other topics. My…

  • Year in review - 2014

    Starting on testosterone therapy and subsequently getting a legal change of name and gender were my most important events of 2014 (and indeed,…

  • Race report: DSE Aquatic Park 10K

    It seems that since VeganMofo 2014 ended I haven't been interested in blogging here much. I have been quite active on Facebook and have been…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.